Products

  • Mega Magic Draw | MEGA

    Treat yourself to the next BIG thing in Thinking Putty®! Our MEGA tin contains one FULL POUND of...
    $40.00
    $40.00
    Sold out
  • Mega tin of Crazy Aaron's Super Scarab Thinking Putty®.

    Mega Super Scarab | Thinking Putty®

    Treat yourself to the next BIG thing in Thinking Putty!  Our MEGA tin contains one FULL POUND of...
    $40.00
    $40.00
    Sold out
  • Mini tin of Crazy Aaron's Mega Watt Thinking Putty®.

    Mega Watt | MINI

    Turn up the voltage with this eye-popping neon purple putty! Bold, bright, and buzzing with energy, Mega Watt...
    $4.00
    $4.00
    Sold out

  • Mermaid Magic | Cloud Slime | Slime Charmers™

    Time to explore the world under the sea with Crazy Aaron's® Slime Charmers™ Mermaid Magic. This beautiful teal...
    $12.00
    $12.00

  • Mermaid Tale® | Glowbrights®

    Fantastical stories will be inspired with Mermaid Tale® Thinking Putty®! The purple and turquoise color shifting sparkles shimmer...
    $15.00
    $15.00
    Sold out

  • Mermaid Tale® | Glowbrights® | 3.5" Tin

    Fantastical stories will be inspired with Mermaid Tale® Thinking Putty®! The purple and turquoise color shifting sparkles shimmer...
    $12.00
    $12.00

  • Merry and Bright | MINI

    It’s the most wonderful time of the year with holiday Thinking Putty® minis! Ring in the season with...
    $4.00
    $4.00
    Sold out

  • Merry Little Minis | MINI Bundle

    Spread the holiday cheer with six mini tins of festive fun! From Winter Cabin coziness to the sparkle...
    $20.00
    $20.00
    Sold out

  • MINI Speckled Egg | GLOW

    Speckled eggs have intricate, beautiful patterns that help birds to identify their own. Hatch some fresh ideas with...
    $4.00
    $4.00
    Sold out

  • Mistletoe Mania | MINI

    Kissing under the mistletoe is a popular folklore tradition at Christmastime! Keep Mistletoe Mania Thinking Putty® on you...
    $4.00
    $4.00
    Sold out

  • Mixed Emotions | Hide Inside!®

    What an emotional roller coaster! Buckle up and spot the "silly" faces within the cluster of smiling ones!...
    $15.00
    $15.00
    Sold out

  • Mountain Lake | MINI

    Catch the sparkle of the lake!  This amazing glitter fileld putty will have the lake dancing in your...
    $4.00
    $4.00
    Sold out

  • Mystic Crystal | MINI

    Crystals are formed into all sorts of unique shapes when a liquid becomes a solid. Some crystals have...
    $4.00
    $4.00

  • Neon Flash | MINI

    Bursting with bold energy, Neon Flash Thinking Putty® is an electrifying neon pink putty shifts to a fiery...
    $4.00
    $4.00
    Sold out

  • No Worries | Trendsetters

    Quiet your thoughts and leave your distractions behind with No Worries Thinking Putty®. The shimmering blue color reflects...
    $15.00
    $15.00
    Sold out

  • Orange Blossom | MINI

    Another of Strawberry Shortcake's berry besties! Bright, citrusy, and oh-so-squishy, this orange-scented putty brings a burst of sunshine...
    $4.00
    $4.00
    Sold out
  • Mini tin of Crazy Aaron's Ornament Thinking Putty®.

    Ornament | MINI

    Start a new tradition with Ornament Thinking Putty®. A holly, jolly red, it shines with golden sparkles and...
    $4.00
    $4.00
    Sold out

  • Over Easy | Liquid Glass | Medium

    Start your day sunny side up with Over Easy! This bright yellow Liquid Glass® Thinking Putty® captures the...
    $6.00
    $6.00
    Sold out

  • Owl | MINI

    Take flight with Crazy Aaron's® Mini Owl Thinking Putty®! Inspired by the majestic snowy owl, this magical putty...
    $4.00
    $4.00
    Sold out

  • Party Animals | Hide Inside!®

    Celebrate good times! The Party Animals have gathered for the wildest party of the year. You're invited to...
    $15.00
    $15.00

  • Peach Ring | Scentsory®

    Peachy keen and totally dreamy! Peach Ring SCENTsory® Putty is a soft, pale orange putty with sparkling specks...
    $8.00
    $8.00
    Sold out

  • Pegasus | Trendsetters

    According to ancient Greek mythology, one of the Greek Gods' favorite creatures is a Pegasus! They look like...
    $15.00
    $15.00
    Sold out

  • Pickleball | MINI

    Fad or Mainstream, it doesn't matter it's FUN! Enjoy the latest craze with our mini tin of Pickleball...
    $4.00
    $4.00

  • Piglet | MINI Tin

    Spring comes once a year! Piglet Sunshine Thinking Putty® will make you squeal with cheer. This mini putty...
    $4.00
    $4.00
    Sold out

Shop Collections

Better Butter

Better Butter

Better Butter

Liquid Glass

Liquid Glass

Mini Tins

Mini Tins

Full-Size Tins

Full-Size Tins

MEGA Tins

MEGA Tins

MEGA Tins

Magnetic Storms

Magnetic Storms

Glow In The Dark

Glow In The Dark

Mix Your Own

Mix Your Own

Pinchies

Pinchies

SCENTsory

SCENTsory

Slime Charmers

Slime Charmers